QQuestionEnglish
QuestionEnglish
"What is one example from ""A Modest Proposal"" in which the narrator's tone doesn't match the topic he is discussing?
A. He describes eating children as a cheap and evenhanded way to solve poverty.
B. He compares Ireland to a desert island where cannibalism is an accepted practice.
C. He says that his plan to eat children was one he heard from a barbaric American.
D. He states that he consulted church and government officials about the plan to eat children."
12 months agoReport content
Answer
Full Solution Locked
Sign in to view the complete step-by-step solution and unlock all study resources.
Step 1:Let's solve this step by step:
Step 2:: Understand the Context
Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" is a satirical essay where the narrator suggests eating children as a solution to Irish poverty. The entire piece is characterized by a deliberately calm, rational tone that starkly contrasts with the horrific suggestion of cannibalism.
Step 3:: Analyze the Tone and Content of Each Option
A. "He describes eating children as a cheap and evenhanded way to solve poverty." - This option perfectly captures the essay's satirical essence - The narrator uses a shockingly matter-of-fact tone to discuss an absolutely horrific proposal - The juxtaposition of "cheap and evenhanded" with child consumption creates a deeply ironic tone
Step 4:: Evaluate the Other Options
B. Comparing Ireland to a cannibalistic desert island - while shocking, doesn't highlight the tone mismatch as clearly C. Attributing the idea to an American doesn't emphasize the tone contradiction D. Mentioning consulting officials doesn't reveal the tone's inappropriate nature
Step 5:: Conclusion
The best example of tone not matching the topic is Option A, where the narrator discusses eating children with a disturbingly rational and casual tone.
Final Answer
The key insight is Swift's use of deadpan, logical language to describe an utterly absurd and horrific proposition, which serves as a powerful satirical critique of British policies toward Irish poverty.
Need Help with Homework?
Stuck on a difficult problem? We've got you covered:
- Post your question or upload an image
- Get instant step-by-step solutions
- Learn from our AI and community of students