QQuestionEthics
QuestionEthics
"Which of the following constitutes both a breach of confidentiality (the research data have been disclosed, counter to the agreement between researcher and subjects) and a violation of subjects’ privacy (the right of the individuals to be protected against intrusion into their personal lives or affairs)?
A researcher asks cocaine users to provide names and contact information of other cocaine users who might qualify for a study.
In order to eliminate the effect of observation on behavior, a researcher attends a support group and records interactions without informing the attendees.
A faculty member makes identifiable data about sexual behavior available to graduate students, although the subjects were assured that the data would be de-identified.
A researcher, who is a guest, audio-records conversations at a series of private dinner parties to assess gender roles, without informing participants."
12 months agoReport content
Answer
Full Solution Locked
Sign in to view the complete step-by-step solution and unlock all study resources.
Step 1:: Identify the breach of confidentiality and violation of privacy in the first scenario.
The first scenario involves a researcher asking cocaine users to provide names and contact information of other cocaine users. This constitutes both a breach of confidentiality and a violation of subjects' privacy. Breach of Confidentiality: The researcher has obtained sensitive information from the initial cocaine users under the agreement that it would be kept confidential. Disclosing this information to others is a direct violation of that agreement. Violation of Privacy: By asking for the names and contact information of other cocaine users, the researcher is intruding into the personal lives and affairs of these individuals, which is a violation of their privacy.
Step 2:: Identify the breach of confidentiality and violation of privacy in the second scenario.
The second scenario involves a researcher attending a support group and recording interactions without informing the attendees. This constitutes a breach of confidentiality and a violation of subjects' privacy. Breach of Confidentiality: The researcher has obtained sensitive information from the support group attendees under the assumption that the discussions were confidential. Failing to inform the attendees and recording the interactions is a violation of that assumed confidentiality. Violation of Privacy: By recording the interactions without the knowledge or consent of the attendees, the researcher is intruding into their personal lives and affairs, which is a violation of their privacy.
Step 3:: Identify the breach of confidentiality and violation of privacy in the third scenario.
The third scenario involves a faculty member making identifiable data about sexual behavior available to graduate students, although the subjects were assured that the data would be de-identified. This constitutes a breach of confidentiality. Breach of Confidentiality: The faculty member has obtained sensitive information from the subjects under the agreement that it would be de-identified. Making the data identifiable is a direct violation of that agreement. Violation of Privacy: Although the scenario does not explicitly mention the violation of subjects' privacy, it can be inferred that the disclosure of identifiable data about sexual behavior could lead to the invasion of subjects' privacy, depending on the context and how the data is used.
Step 4:: Identify the breach of confidentiality and violation of privacy in the fourth scenario.
The fourth scenario involves a researcher audio-recording conversations at a series of private dinner parties to assess gender roles, without informing participants. This constitutes a breach of confidentiality and a violation of subjects' privacy. Breach of Confidentiality: The researcher has obtained sensitive information from the dinner party participants under the assumption that the conversations were confidential. Failing to inform the participants and recording the conversations is a violation of that assumed confidentiality. Violation of Privacy: By audio-recording the conversations without the knowledge or consent of the participants, the researcher is intruding into their personal lives and affairs, which is a violation of their privacy.
Final Answer
In all four scenarios, there is a breach of confidentiality and a violation of subjects' privacy, as the researchers have obtained sensitive information under the assumption of confidentiality and then disclosed or used the information in a way that intrudes upon the subjects' personal lives and affairs.
Need Help with Homework?
Stuck on a difficult problem? We've got you covered:
- Post your question or upload an image
- Get instant step-by-step solutions
- Learn from our AI and community of students