Skip to content
Textbook Guides

Managing Quality: Integrating the Supply Chain, 6th Edition Solution Manual

Managing Quality: Integrating the Supply Chain, 6th Edition Solution Manual makes solving textbook questions easier with expertly crafted solutions.

Preview 31 of 262 pages

See the first 31 pages exactly as they appear in the document.

  1. Page 1
    Read page 1 as text

    Page 1 of 13 Chapter 1: Differing Perspectives on Quality Chapter Outline • Differing Perspectives on Quality ▪ What is Quality ? ▪ Recognizing both Product and Service Dimensions of Quality ▪ Differing Functional Perspectives on Quality ▪ Three Spheres of Quality ▪ Other Perspectives on Quality ▪ Arriving at a Common Understanding of Quality U sing a Contingency Perspective of Quality Overview The entire concept of quality is what one of my professors once called an “arm - waiver . ” We all intuitively know what it means, yet when w e are asked to explain it , we just sort of wave our arms. Chapter 1 defines the terms. The author references various definitions of quality. He makes the distinction between s ervice and m anufacturing from a quality perspective and delves into “The Su pply Chain . ” Consideration of quality as it applies to the modern supply chain expands our understanding of its application. Professor Foster has taken the concept of the s upply c hain and made it integral to the subject of quality. Any book on quality must discuss Deming. The a uthor makes reference to Deming throughout the book. The focal point of the chapter is the question “What is Quality ? ” Professor Foster supplies a list of topics product and service quality that can be ideally used in a class discussion: • Performance • Features • Reliability • Conformance • Durability • Tangibles • Service reliability • Responsiveness • Assurance • Empathy • Availability • Professionalism • Timeliness

  2. Page 2
  3. Page 3
    Read page 3 as text

    Page 2 of 13 The author looks at quality from different perspectives. This list is also an excellent starting point for class discussion: • Supply chain • Engineering • Operations • Strategic management • Marketing • Financial • Human resources Figure 1 - 1 A Global Supply Chain Model Source: Foster, S. Thomas; Sampson, Scott E.; Wallin, Cynthia; Webb, Scott W, Managing Supply Chain And Operations: An Integrative Approach, 1st Ed., © 2016, p.15. Reprinted and Electronically reproduced by permission of Pearson Education, Inc., New York, NY. Chapter 1 will ideally fit into a standard 100 - minute class perio d.

  4. Page 4
    Read page 4 as text

    Page 3 of 13 Discussion Questions 1. Why is quality a difficult term to define? How can we improve our understanding of quality? This is an ideal question to open the discussion of the topic of q uality. Ask the class to define q uality and record their comments. You will typically find a myriad of answers , but there should be a common theme among them. 2. Briefly discuss Garvin’s eight dimensions of quality. Is Garvin’s multidimensional approach a step forward in improving our understanding of quality? Why or why not? Garvin lists the following: • Performance • Features • Reliability • Conformance • Durability • Serviceability • Aesthetics • Perceived quality Using Garvin’s terminology, these terms identify five different aspects of quality. One might say, “Quality is in the eye of the consumer.”

  5. Page 5
    Read page 5 as text

    Page 4 of 13 3. Is there a difference between service quality and product quality? If so, what are the implications of these differences for a manager of a service business, such as a restaurant or a retail store? Service quality suggests an achievement in a level of customer service and is more subjective than the definition of product quality that is related to a tangible product . Service quality is more difficult to define because of its numerous customer variations , and it is therefore more difficult to achieve quality success based on this wide latitude of customer opinion. You can demonstrate this in class buy surveying , for example , the service quality of a major brand ( e.g., AT&T, Verizon, etc.) and then surveying the opinions of the class regarding one or more service quality dimensions. 4. Define the concept of empathy. On page 6 , the concept of empathy is discussed: Finally, consumers of services desire empathy from the service provider. In other words, the customer desires caring, individualized attention from the service firm. The author’s discussion of empathy uses the relationship between a waiter and customer. You might extend this conversation by asking for other examples. Does empathy enter into a man ufacturing situation? Dilbert’s Pointy - Haired - Manager is an excellent tool for this discussion. 5. Why is communication within an organization an important part of the quality improvement process? On page 6 , the author says: It is difficult to devise a coherent strategic plan relating to quality when communication is imprecise. Think about the people involved. Do the marketer, engineer, order processor , and manager all speak the “same language ? ” Communication enables planning. In a multidimensiona l environment , communication becomes more difficult simply due to different backgrounds. How do you make this happen? What are the priorities that must be shared? 6. Compare and contrast the e ngineering perspective and marketing perspective of quality? How could an overemphasis on the engineering perspective work to the disadvantage of a business organization? The textbook ( p age 13 ) says: The marketer focuses on the perceived quality of products and services as opposed to the engineering based conformance definition of quality. The question then asks whether the engineering approach could be self - defeating. This is pretty much a follow - up to question 5. Do the communications styles and background s influence the marketer and the engineer? W hat are the goals of the

  6. Page 6
    Read page 6 as text

    Page 5 of 13 engineer? What are the goals of the marketer? Do they coincide or conflict ? What should the goals be in an efficiently run organization? 7. Describe the “systems view” that underlies modern quality management thinking. Which of the perspectives of quality discussed in C hapter 1 is most closely aligned with the systems view? Some discussion questions might be: A. What is the systems view? B. What do the approaches have in common? C. How are the approaches different? D. How do the different approaches affect the ultimate consumer? This diagram depicts the basic approach to planning.

  7. Page 7
    Read page 7 as text

    Page 6 of 13 8. Why is planning an important part of the quality process? How could a firm’s quality management initiatives be adversely affected if planning was not a part of the process? Refer back to the question on communication ( q uestion 5). You might review Garvin’s list: • Performance • Features • Reliability • Conformance • Durability • Serviceability • Aesthetics • Perceived quality Which of these are the most dependent upon planning? Are any of them unaffected by planning? Does poor planning adversely affect any of these items more than others? 9. Research has shown that quality is still a major concern of the majority of CEOs in American corporations. Is this level of concern about quality warranted? Please explain your answer. A discussion about the competition between American and foreign products would be productive. How has the automotive industry been affected by the apparent quality or lack of quality of foreign cars? Have other industries been affected in this manner? Has the movement of our nation from manufacturing to service been affected by quality, either actual or perceived? 10 . What is meant by the phrase cost of quality ? How can this phrase help a firm address its quality concerns? The article Quality Strategy at GE contains the following statement: GE denied that such problems forced GE to adopt its new quality program. “We are not in trouble,” they said, citing the robust profits. But they conceded that “the time wasted, the money wasted, in field fixes, in quality problems, in working things out, across corporate America, across the world, is enormous.” Does this give you any insight into the attitudes at GE after Welch’s departure? What other aspects that have been discussed apply here? Look at the American automobile industry again. Is the comparison that is being made between GE and the American a utomobile industry valid? How does long - range planning affect quality in cases like these?

  8. Page 8
    Read page 8 as text

    Page 7 of 13 11 . What are the major differences between traditional human resource management and total quality human resource management? How does total quality human resource management transcend tradition al human resource management in regard to providing an environment that is supportive of quality concerns? The table below lays out the question succinctly. This table should be an excellent springboard for in - class discussion . HRM versus TQHRM Traditional HRM TQHRM Process characteristics Unilateral role Consulting role Centralization Decentralization Pull Release Administrative Developmental Content characteristics Nomothetic Pluralistic Compartmentalized Holistic Worker - oriented System - oriented Performance measures Satisfaction measures Job - based Person - base SOURCE: Adapted from R. Cardy and G. H. Dobbins, “Human Resources Management in a Total Quality Environment,” Journal of Quality Management 1, 1 (1996):3. 12 . Describe the three spheres of quality. How do these spheres provide another way to place the field of quality in perspective?

  9. Page 9
    Read page 9 as text

    Page 8 of 13 Notice the three quality descriptors: • Management • Assurance • Control How do they differ? How are they the same? Notice that the Venn diagram above shows overlap. What are the imp lications of the overlapped area s ? Where does quality management end and where does quality assurance begin? How does quality control fit into the picture? 13 . Discuss the value - added perspectiv e on quality. What are the implications of this perspective for the manager of a business organization? A value - added activity can be pinpointed by asking, “Would this activity matter to the customer?” In other words, in most cases, a value - added activity will have economic value to the customer. Looking back at the GE example that is discussed in question 10 : • How does value added enter into the discussion? • Look at our consumer goods: does the concept of value added influence your purchasing decision s? • Can you actually identify a value - added component? • Is value added more obvious by it presence or absence? More generally, how is quality a value - added item? Getting back to the automobile industry, how did the influx of Japanese cars in the 19 60s reflect on the concept of quality adding value to a product? 14 . How does contingency theory inform decision making when implementing improvement efforts? Page 19 states: Contingency theory presupposes that there is no theory or method for operating a business that can be applied in all instances A company that defines part of its mission as "valuing and satisfying our customers through personalized service" likely will pursue a different technological approach toward its customers than a company with the mission of "applying technology to solve customer problems . " The contingency approach to quality also helps settle the different perceptions concerning the definition of quality, for example: • Do you as a consumer feel that quality is not as important in a lower priced item? • When a product has been on the market for an extended period of time, do you

  10. Page 10
    Read page 10 as text

    Page 9 of 13 still observe quality? • Do you have different expectations of quality for a high priced item than you do for an inexpensive item? Why? • Do you have the same expectation of quality on similarly priced items based upon their use or application, for example, food vs. clothing? 15 . Should a firm consider the law of diminishing marginal returns when striving to improve quality? Why or why not? On p age 14 , the statement is made that there is a point where the continued quest for quality b ecomes uneconomical. Figure 1 - 6 illustrates this concept. Is there a subtle problem here? How might the quality of one product affect the perception of overall product quality? How does the cost of quality affect other products when the cost of quality on another product has proven uneconomic al ? In that situation, what choices exist? Can you think of any examples? 16 . Are the perspectives of quality independent of one another? If not, describe ways in which they are interrelated. This chapter is named Differing Perspectives on Quality . Does the author make the point? List the perspectives and identify the differences and similarities. Are there any trends or common points? On what are these perspectives based ? Given the preceding questions, what conclusions can you make? 17 . How can an understanding of the multiple dimensions of quality lead to improved product and service designs? As identified earlier, Garvin identified eight dimensions of quality: • Performance • Features • Reliability • Conformance • Durability • Serviceability • Aesthetics • Perceived quality Do they apply differently to products or services? How does each of these dimensions directly apply to a product or a service? 18 . What is your concept of quality? Is it multidimensional, or does it focus on a single dimension such as features, reliability, or conformance? Explain your answer .

  11. Page 11
    Read page 11 as text

    Page 10 of 13 Do you react differently as a consumer or a supplier? Can you use these attitudes in business? As we have discussed, marketing and manufacturing approach quality from different perspectives. What are the common points? How does management deal with the differences or the similarities ? 19 . Describe an instance in which you and a coworker (or superior) perceived the needs of a customer very differently. How did your differences in perception influence how each of you wanted to meet your customer’s needs? What aspects of quality made the most difference to you or your co - worker? Does your superior view quality in the same manner as you do? Why? In the class environment, do your needs and expectations differ from that of your instructors? Does the question of quality differ for you and your instructor s ?

  12. Page 12
    Read page 12 as text

    Page 11 of 13 Case Study 1 - 1 : FedEx: Managing Quality Day and Night This cast study provides insight into the unique problems faced by a service - based company. Central to this discussion are three questions that the company asks its employees: 1. What do you need from me? 2. What do you do with what I give you? 3. Are there any gaps between what I give you and what I need? This case also introduces the topic of Quality Improvement Process ( QIP ) . This might be a good time to set the tone of future lectures. This case study might be an excellent one to use early in the semester . Case Questions: 1. What is FedEx’s “common language” of quality? Is it important for a company to establish a “common language” of quality? If so, why? How does Fedex’s three - pronged “People - Service - Profit” reflect quality? How does Fedex’s twelve component “Service Quality Indicator” reduc e communications difficulties. 2. There are several different perspectives of quality, including the operations perspective, the strategic perspective, the marketing perspective, the financial perspective, the HR perspective, and the systems perspective. Which of these perspectives are being emphasized by FedEx? Why? Does the “ c ommon l anguage” allow personnel to cross boundaries? Does inclusion of management in the teams affect the concept of quality? The SQI is a cross - functional tool. How does this affect the situation? The case states that the SQI “e nsures the involvement of frontline employees, support personnel, and managers from all parts of the corporation when needed. ” Do the employee incentives assist this as well? 3. Is FedEx’s level of emphasis on quality appropriate? Why or why not? Who is FedEx’s competition? Is quality a focal point in this industry? How does the customer measure quality? What specific attributes do the customers use to judge quality?

  13. Page 13
    Read page 13 as text

    Page 12 of 13 C ase Study 1 - 2 : Granite Rock Company: Achieving Quality through Employees This case presents quality through the management perspective. A strategy for using this case might be to ask the students to list the specific steps taken by Management to address the quality issue. The case also discusses the individual employees IPDP, the Individual Personal Development Plan. It might be interesting to contrast this approach with both Managing by Objectives (MBO) and Managing by Exception (MBE). These are two methods of management that have gained a major foothold in industry and could yield a good discussion. Case Questions: 1. Rather than focusing on human resource management (HRM) as a means of supporting its quality initiatives, Granite Rock could have chosen another area as its focal point (i.e., marketing, operations, information systems, and so on). How does a focus on HRM support a company’s quality initiatives? This statement might be the key: The managers at Granite Rock knew that a resulting decline in customer satisfaction was inevitable and responded to this self - assessment by deciding it needed to become more customer focused . … As explained by CEO Bruce Woolpert, you can’t have employees out telling customers “yes” unless everyone else in the company knows how to follow up on “yes.” How does the focus on individual employee growth fit within the guidelines of HRM? 2. Discuss the different components of Granite Rock’s HRM initiatives. How can each of these components support the company’s quality efforts? The list of initiative s might include: • Employee t raining • Individual Personal Training Plan (IDPD) • Atmosphere of trust between management and rank - and - file • Winning the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award While on the surface these might seem to be independent items, how are they related in actuality? What is the effect o f these items on the individual employee? 3. Discuss CEO Woolpert’s feelings about communication with the customers (paragraph 2). What happens when others in the company don’t know what has been promised to the customer? How can quality management help to overcome this situation ? The key sentence in this paragraph is: As explained by CEO Bruce Woolpert, you can’t have employees out telling customers “yes” unless everyone else in the company knows how to follow up on “yes.”

  14. Page 14
    Read page 14 as text

    Page 13 of 13 While there had been discussion of the impact that management has upon quality , i f the employees do not feel empowered , quality will suffer. Do the actions that are directly aimed at the employees affect quality? This communication is perhaps the core of the topic . Websites of Interest http://www.nist.gov/baldrige/ -- The home site for the Baldridge National Quality Program http://www.asq.org/learn - about - quality/quality - tools.html -- American Society for Quality http://www.thecqi.org/ -- Chartered Quality Institute http://www.managementhelp.org/plan_dec/mbo/mbo.htm -- A detailed look at Management by Objectives http://www.ge.com/en/company/companyinfo/quality/whatis.htm -- An overview of Six Sigma from GE’s perspective

  15. Page 15
    Read page 15 as text

    Page 1 of 13 Chapter 2: Quality Theory Chapter Outline • Quality Theory ▪ What is Theory ? ▪ Leading C ontributors to Quality Theory • W. Edward Deming • Joseph M. Duran • Kaoru Ishikawa • Armand Feigenbaum • Philip Crosby • Genichi Taguchi • The R est of the P ack ▪ Viewing Quality from a Contingency Perspective ▪ Resolving the Differences in Quality Approaches: An Integrative Approach Overview When the author discusses theory, he is not being philosophical; rather he discusses the major “players” and their contributions to the subject. O n page 26 , the point is made that “there is not a unified theory explaining quality improvement.” The author also makes a statement that quality improvement is positively linked to employee morale. He links q uality i mprovement to the classic Theory X approach to management (and Theory Z for that matter) .

  16. Page 16
    Read page 16 as text

    Page 2 of 13 Discussion Questions 1. Define theory. Why are theories important for managing quality in the supply chain? The author states that in order for a theory to be complete, it has to answer the se questions: • What? • How? • Why? • Who ? • Where ? • When? How does p ractice relate to t heory ? You might also ask how this relates to the classic definition of theory that we have studied in other disciplines. The model the text presents is illustrated in Figure 2 - 1. A positive correlation is presented between Quality Improvement and Worker Morale. To verify the model, we conduct statistical research. This will either prove or disprove the theory. 2. Describe the differences between induction and deduction. If you developed a theory based solely on your experiences of quality practices in business organizations, would you be basing your theory on induction or deduction? Why ? On page 25 , the text discusses a Morale Check at a Chicago - based company just after the Cubs won the World Series. Morale is found to be positive. Students must decide: is this inductive or deductive? What are examples of i nductive and deductive theory f ro m the class’s perspective. If one looks at the classic theories – Evolution, Relatively, Theory X, Y , and Z – are the y individually inductive or deductive?

  17. Page 17
    Read page 17 as text

    Page 3 of 13 If the theory is generated by observation and experience, the theory is inductive. If the theory is developed through the Scientific method , it is deductive. Does the fact that in the case the Cubs just won the World Series apply? Does this make the theory deductive or inductive? 3. Do you believe that the development of a unified theory of quality management is possible? What is a unified theory? On page 26 , “A Closer Look at Quality - The Product T hat is Quality” looks at the different approaches to quality. As you discuss the key players, this might be a good question to keep going on the side. Einstein spent most of his later life searching for a unified theory in physics. He failed. Do unified theories exist in any discipline? What would the implications be if there was a unified theory for quality management? If you contrast the approaches of the major players, do they all take the same approach? Does the fact that we are dealing with people affect this situation? 4. Why do managers need to be cautious about purchasing material (e.g., courses, workbooks, videos, and so on) on quality management from trainers and consultants? How would you go about selecting this type of material? In the quoted article , The Product That is Quality , the statement is made that , “ Within each approach, corporate managers are confronted by a numbing maze of acronyms and buzzwords. There is TQC, TQM, fishbone diagramming, cause and effect, poka yoke, big Q, and little q. ” An entire industry has sprung up just to provide material to support quality initiatives . The Juran Institute sells a $15,000 do - it - yourself kit complete with 16 videotapes, 10 workbooks, a leader’s manual, overhead transparencies, and a five - day course to teach someone how to run the tapes . Harvard’s Garvin observes that all of the Baldrige Award winners had developed their own approach to quality. The most effective way to develop a solid quality approach is to have it developed in - house. 5. Briefly describe the contributions W. Edwards Deming made to the field of quality management. Why do you believe he is the most influential quality expert? Deming outlined 14 points for m anagement:

  18. Page 18
    Read page 18 as text

    Page 4 of 13 In the 1950s , Japanese - made products were frequently called inferior, tinny , and shoddy. Today, names such as Toyota and Sony are equated with high - quality manufacturing. Deming stressed that consumers are well served by insisting that service and product providers deliver high quality. He believed that the more consumers demand high - quality products and services, the more firms will continually aspire to higher levels of performance. As opposed to 20 years ago, consumers now expect high - quality products at a reasonable cost. 6. Deming believed poor quality was not the fault of workers but resulted from poor management of the system for quality improvement. Do you agree with Deming’s stand on this issue? Why or why not? Answers here will vary. Some things to consider: Deming raises the topic of “continual, never - ending improvement.” How does this place the responsibility for quality on the shoulders of management? What does this philosophy say about Deming’s general approach to management? A key motivator in our culture is looking for the source of the problem. Deming places the problem in management ’ s lap. How do today’s management philosophies either support or deny this approach? Think about Theory X and Y. Research Ouchi’s Theory Z. Also consider Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. Is there commonality in the se philosophies? 7. Deming was not an advocate of mass inspection as a means of ensuring product quality. Please explain Deming’s beliefs in this area. Taken out of context, the statement is curious. However, from page 29 , we read: “Eliminate the need for inspection on a mass basis by building quality into the product in the first place.” Is Deming discussing the place that quality must have in the general context of the process? Is quality a feature that you add on at the end of the process? How revolutionary is this statement? How does the popular literature about management address this attitude? If you tie this back to the discussion of Jack Welch in C hapter 1, the importance of visionary leadership is identified. Goldratt 1 discusses the t heory of c onstraints. He says that c onstraints, or bottlenecks, affect the flow of product through the system. Can q uality be a constraint? 8. Select one of Deming’s 14 points for management and describe how this point could have resulted in quality improvements in a business or volunteer organization with which you have been involved. Every successful manager can point to failures in his or her past. The difference between a successful manager and an unsuccessful manager is how he or she reacts to those 1 http://www.goldratt.com/

  19. Page 19
    Read page 19 as text

    Page 5 of 13 failures. Although this concept is seldom discussed, writers like Deming and Juran are sharing the remedies, either made or observed, to past failures. The success of these writers is based upon the fact that they can help the new manager avoid the common, but not obvious , pitfalls. Any person who has had a position of authority should be able to read Deming ’ s list and identify a mistake that was made relating to each one. This should prove to be a fascinating classroom session, especially if the professor joins in the discussion and adds his or her own experiences. 9. Briefly describe the contributions that Joseph M. Juran made to the field of quality management. What do you believe was Juran’s most significant contribution? Juran discusses three processes: planning, control, and improvement. He states that these processes are sequential : first planning, then control, and the n improvement. Juran’s emphasis is on continued improvement – c ontrol, not b reakthrough. Juran uses Pareto’s law, the 80%/20% rule , to identify the quality problems. 10. Is the concept of scientific management compatible with employee empowerment? Why or why not? Frederick W. Taylor launched scientific management. It separated planning from execution. Taylor gave the planning function to managers and engineers. He limited supervisors and workers to the function of executing the plans. The result of the “Taylor Revolution ” was centralizing the quality function. How does this approach fit within the framework established by Deming? Taylor published his treatise in 1911. How has the culture of the workplace evolved since then? 11. Does the phrase “quality is the responsibility of the quality department” reflect a healthy perspective of quality management? Please explain your answer. This revolves around the question , “ Whose job is quality? ” By centralizing quality, Taylor removed it from the day - to - day operation of the company. As the topic of quality is removed from the production floor, what is management’s response going to be? If we look back at Juran, is this now a control or a breakthrough function? Why? Taylor notes that by delegating quality to the quality manager, the line supervisors and managers could devote their own time to other matters. As they did so, they became progressively less and less informed about quality. When a quality problem develop ed , management lack ed the expertise needed to choose a proper course of action.

  20. Page 20
    Read page 20 as text

    Page 6 of 13 12. Briefly describe the Japanese quality revolution following World War II. What can modern day managers learn from studying the history of this era? After the war, the industrial leaders in Japan turned their attention toward improving the quality of Japanese manufactured goods. The quality revolution in Japan was initiated through the following steps : • They sent teams abroad to learn how foreign countries achieved quality. • They translated foreign literature into Japanese. • They invited Deming to lecture in Japan and listened carefully to Deming's views on quality. To the credit of the Japanese people, they implemented what they learned about quality management, and in many cases , eventually improved on what they learned. The result was a virtual quality revolution in Japan in the years following World War II. 13. What was Joseph Juran’s primary contribution to quality thinking in America? Discuss Juran’s three - step process to improving quality. Juran’s three - step process was: • Planning • Control • Improvement This three - step process emphasized control over breakthrough. This was a major step towards ongoing quality improvement, rather than mass inspections. This approach moved the process of quality to the lowest possible level. 14. Hothouse quality refers to those quality programs that receive a lot of hoopla and no follow - through. Provide several examples of management practices that can lead to hothouse quality. How can hothouse quality be avoided? Management practices that are focused on achieving short - term objectives and/or immediate results are susceptible to hothouse quality. Hothouse qual ity programs often promise dramatic increases in performance over a relatively short period of time. Consistently productive decision makers typically see this as an unrealistic goal, and avoid these types of programs. Less successful decision makers and decision makers desperate to see quality improvement quickly may be more prone to investigate these programs.

  21. Page 21
    Read page 21 as text

    Page 7 of 13 15. Compare and contrast Deming’s, Juran’s, and Crosby’s perspectives of quality management. What are the major similarities and differences between their perspectives? Deming addressed the entire process and focused primarily on the assertion that poor quality is not the fault of the worker, but is the fault of the system. Deming also strongly opposed the creation of quality inspection departme nts. He felt that q uality should not be the responsibility of the quality inspection departments. It should be built into the product. Juran's work focuses on the idea that organizational quality problems are largely the result of insufficient and ineffective planning for quality. In addition, Juran fleshed out many of the implementation issues involved with quality through his trilogy. Crosby made two key points in his arguments about the responsibility of the quality department, and not the individual worker. Crosby has enjoyed the most commercial success of the three. First, he argued that quality, as a managed process, could be a source of profi t for an organization. Second, Crosby adopted a "zero defects" approach to quality management, and emphasized the behavioral and motivational aspects of quality improvement rather than statistical approaches. Similarities: All three men were very passionate about the role of quality in business organizations, and felt that quality is a process that must be deliberately managed. In addition, all three of them saw quality as the focal point for organizational performance an d effectiveness. Differences: Deming and Juran were more statistically oriented in their approach than Crosby. The each emphasized different aspects of quality management in their approaches. Crosby's zero def ects approach probably goes further than would be advocated by Deming or Juran. Crosby was also more prolific than Deming and Juran in terms of the production of quality - related materials (e.g., videos, workbooks, lecture series, etc.). 16. Describe Taguchi’s perspective of ideal quality. Does this perspective have practical applications? If you were a manager, would you consider using the Taguchi method? Why? Table 2 - 4 on page 37 provides an overview of the Taguchi method.

  22. Page 22
    Read page 22 as text

    Page 8 of 13 Taguchi accomplishes these steps by emphasizing a three - fold approach to quality: • The definition of quality • The quality loss function • The concept of robust design A key element of the Taguchi concept is that of robust design. This states that products and services should be designed so that they are inherently defect - free and of high quality. Taguchi sets his target high. The overall effect of this is desirable and accomplishable. 17. Why do you think that reengineering programs have such a high failure rate? Can you think of ways to improve the success rate of reengineering programs? Reengineering bypasses the analysis and design steps and tries to piggyback on the past successes of others. Reengineering programs have experienced a high failure rate primarily because they tend to oversimplify extremely complex or ganizational issues , and as a result, do not focus managers on the attention to detail and analysis that is necessary to effect meaningful (and effective) organizational change. Reengineering programs would probably be more successful if they were combined with more traditional and well - founded approaches to effective organizational change. 18. Describe how the contingency perspective helps us understand why a single approach to quality management may never emerge. The text states that firms that are successful in quality do not adopt a blanket “Deming approach to quality.” These firms utilize the applicable approaches that help them improve. The author discusses this as the contingency perspective . The direction is that different quality problems mandate different quality imp rovement approaches. On page 40 , the author states: From your own perspective, you need to make correct quality - related decisions. In doing this, you should consider the different quality experts in this chapter and choose those concepts and approaches that make sense for you . 19. How can a philosophy of quality improvement help a firm in its overall efforts of improving the quality of its products and services? The one common element of all these approaches is that quality cannot be an adjunct to the process. Quality must be an integral part of the development. For this to happen, a philosophy of quality improvement must be ingrained into the corporate culture. The point is made that quality starts in the design phase and c ontinues through the product manufacture Any major change to a corporate culture must have full support from top management. Quality is not any different.

  23. Page 23
    Read page 23 as text

    Page 9 of 13 20. Do you believe that CEOs and business managers should be skeptical about the quality movement, or should they embrace the quality movement and try to involve their firms in as many quality initiatives as possible? Please explain your answer . The key to this question may be the phrase "as many quality initiatives as possible." Any project requires planning. The more of an effect a project will have on a firm, the more careful the planning must be. Integrating a quality program is no exception. Every part of the firm is affected. Poor planning can be disastrous.

  24. Page 24
    Read page 24 as text

    Page 10 of 13 Case 2 - 1 : Rheaco, Inc.: Making a Quality Turnabout byAsking for Advice Discussion Questions: 1. Many companies fail in their efforts to improve quality without ever having asked for advice. In your opinion, what are some of the reasons that inhibit firms from asking for timely advice? If you were a manager at Rheaco, would you have sought out an agency like the ARRI? Many companies get into “ f ire f ighting m ode.” They are so busy solving immediate problems that no one has time to dig into the cause of the problems. Many of Deming’s 14 points speak to this problem: Adopting a new philosophy ( point 2), d riving out fear ( point 8) , and r emove barriers to pride ( point 12), all seem to be based on point 7, i mprove l eadership. The problem is that sometimes leadership does not realize that they are the roadblocks. Firms can be insulated. Cultures can be stagnant. One solution is e nsuring that management participates in professional organizations. Another solution might be encouraging employees to continue their education and bring in ideas from their classes. A firm such as ARRI can be i n the vanguard of conceptual development. The major problem is finding out that they exist. 2. Discuss ARRI’s recommendations to Rheaco. How did these recommendations help Rheaco improve its product quality? First, AARI helped Rheaco develop an Enterprise Excellence Plan, which acted as a roadmap for Rheaco's improvement efforts. Consistent with this effort, AARI helped Rheaco i mplement several standard quality improvement programs, including cellular manufacturing, just - in - time inventory control, total quality management, and employee empowerment. Through this process, AARI worked in partnership with Rheaco to imple ment the recommended initiatives and to gradually turn over the change process to Rheaco itself. Other improvements were made, particularly in the areas of shipping and receiving, inventory control, and human resource management. Collectively, these changes had a profound influence on Rheaco's ability to improve its product quality.

  25. Page 25
    Read page 25 as text

    Page 11 of 13 A key statement is made on page 46 : After ARRI had been working with Rheaco for a period of time, the company started identifying and correcting problem on its own, which is exactly what is supposed to happen. People want to succeed. In an environment where success is rewarded , people will thrive and bring the co mpany along with them . 3. ARRI’s initial evaluation of Rheaco indicated that Rheaco’s employees, despite the company’s difficulties, had an overall positive attitude. Do you believe that this factor contributed to ARRI’s ability to provide Rheaco advice? Why or why not? Most students will say that the attitude of Rheaco's employees was a significant factor in AARI's ability to pro vide Rheaco advice. As discussed in Chapter 1, it is impossible to implement quality without the commitment and action of employees. Because Rheaco's employees had a positive attitude, the company started its quality improvement efforts with o ne major obstacle already overcome. It would have been much more difficult for Rheaco to accomplish what it did if it would have had to first convince its em ployees that it was doing the right thing. However, it is important to understand why the employees’ morale was positive in the first place? How does management style enter into this? Could this enterprise have been possible if management did not establish a positive environment? Figure 2.6 on page 44 identifies the role of leadership. In this diagram, everything rev olves around l eadership.

  26. Page 26
    Read page 26 as text

    Page 12 of 13 Case 2 - 2: Has Disney Developed a Theory of Quality Guest Services Management? Discussion Questions: 1. Is Disney’s level of emphasis on anticipating the behavior of its guests appropriate, or does the company expend too much effort in this area? Explain your answer. Before Disneyland, carnivals had a reputation as being seedy and unscrupulous. Walt Disney saw the need for a family - friendly wholesome theme park. In fact, Disneyland was the very first theme park. The success of Disneyland and Disneyworld justifies the process. All successful theme parks have followed the Disney model. Deming’s 14 points continuously emphasizes the value of customer satisfaction. The guest is the customer. 2. Is it appropriate to think in terms of developing a “theory” of how guests will behave in a theme park or any other setting? If so, why? On page 2 6 the text discusses this topic thusly: The text goes on to discuss this topic in A Closer Look At Quality 2 - 1 :

  27. Page 27
    Read page 27 as text

    Page 13 of 13 Is there a difference between the way t heme p arks anticipate their guests’ behavior and the way a supermarket arranges their shelving display to optimize sales? 3. Think about the last time that you visited a theme park. Were your expectations met? Did you have a sense that the operator of the park attempts to “anticipate” the behavior of the guests? If so, provide some specific examples. This question can best be answered on a personal basis. What experiences did the class have at theme parks? Theme parks are not inexpensive places. Was the general consensus that value was there? Will they return? Who is the audience that the theme park targets : parents, children, or subsections of the population? An interesting aspect is the question: Why was Disneyland, Paris not as succe ssful as other Disney efforts?

  28. Page 28
    Read page 28 as text

    Page 1 of 15 Chapter 3: Global Supply Chain Quality and International Quality Standards Chapter Outline • Managing Quality for the Multinational Firm • Quality Improvement: o The American Way o The Japanese Way o The European Way o The Chinese Way • ISO 9000:2008 • Are Quality Approaches Influenced By Culture? Overview The task of managing quality is affected by increased globalization. This chapter discusses the opportunities and obstacles created by globalization. The differences between regions of the world also include discussions of various quality approaches that have been developed in those regions and the awards that act as quality barometers within each. In an increasing ly globalizing economy, it is important to understand the approaches that various nations use to improve quality. It is clear that the trend is toward greater participation in a global economy. As a result, the worker of the future will need to adapt to approaches having roots in other cultures.

  29. Page 29
    Read page 29 as text

    Page 2 of 15 In this chapter, the global economy was discusse d and the role quality plays in that world economy. We considered different quality models from different regions. From an integrative perspective, it is reasonable to borrow from all these models if it help s a firm perform better. The underlying theme in the chapter is the importance of learning from other cultures to compete effectively. Discussion Questions 1. What are the advantages or disadvantages of licensing as a means of gaining access to foreign markets? Through licensing, a firm expands its market and retains earnings made in a foreign market. With markets as large as China, this is a considerable amount. A licensor may also have an existing marketing establishment and existing contacts. The cultural aspects are also worth considering: a product’s name or logo might well be considered offensive in a foreign market. A good example is the Chevrolet Nova. In Spanish , “nova” means “doesn’t go.” A local partner would observe the problem. However, t he disadvantages can be large also. The firm shares its profits with a foreign firm, rather than selling the product or service itself in the foreign country. 2. What are the advantages and disadvantages of globalization? Provide an example of a firm that has engaged in globalization. What are some of the potential advantages and disadvantages of globalization for this particular organization? The primary advantage of globalization is that a firm retains all of the profits from the sale of its products or services in a foreign country. This is a significant advantage when one thinks about the potential of a foreign market like China, which has over one billion potential consumers. As Figure 3 - 2 illustrates, the physical environment, the technical environment , and the social environment affect quality. These factors are dependent upon the local culture to a great degree.

  30. Page 30
    Read page 30 as text

    Page 3 of 15 The primary disadvantage of globalization is that it is complicated and forces a firm to , in essence , "set up shop" in a foreign country. By going abroad, a firm significantly change s the physical environment, the task environment, and the societal environment in which it operate s . This may result in a number of challenges, ranging from becoming familiar with a foreign culture to determining how to get the raw materials that a firm needs to manufacture its product to a foreign destination. IBM is an example of a company that engages in globalization. IBM manufactures products in many countries of the world. The major advantage to globalization for IBM is that it vastly increases the number of potential customers for its computer hardware products. However , IBM’s dark - suit culture may be considered foreign in many parts of the world. 3. What motivates U.S. firms to compete for the Malcolm Baldrige Award? How could a firm benefit from participating in the Baldrige competition, even if it did not apply for the award? Malcolm Baldrige was Secretary of Commerce from 1981 until his death in July 1987. Baldrige was a proponent of quality management as a key to the U.S. ’s prosperity and long - term strength. He took a personal interest in the quality improvement act that was eventually named after him and helped draft one of the early versions. In recognition of his contributions, Congress named the award in his honor. 1 As Figure 3 - 5 on page 56 illustrates, the Baldrige A ward recognizes the interrelationship between the various facets of the organization. 1 http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/factseet/baldfaqs

  31. Page 31
    Read page 31 as text

    Page 4 of 15 There is great prestige in winning the Baldrige A ward. Firms that do not win the award but receive a site visit from Baldrige examiners often include in their company brochures and other promotional material a mention of themselves as being "Baldrige Qualified." The Baldrige Award, or even being Baldrige Qualified, helps firms attract high - quality suppliers, customers, and other stakeholders. The attention to quality from being involved in the Baldrige A ward helps a firm establish a culture of quality and helps a firm rally its employees around quality improvement efforts. 4. Category 3 of the Baldrige criteria focuses on the importance of the customer in assessing the quality of the products and services that a firm sells. Why do you think the authors of the Baldrige criteria included this category? How is the customer important in assessing the quality of the products and services that a company sells? Ishikawa’s second point is: The first step in quality is to know the requirements of the customer . Deming, Juran, Feigenbaum and Parasuraman, Zeithamel, and Berr y – all directly address the customer. Figure 2 - 5 directly places “ Customer Role” at the c ore of q uality m anagement

231 more pages in the full document

Unlock it once and it stays in your library, ready to chat with or turn into flashcards.

Unlock the full document
See all

Study this document with CramX

Once it is in your library, every tool can work from it.