Skip to content
Solved Assignments

CIV 3702 Assignment 1

This assignment explores civil procedure in South Africa, covering court jurisdiction, reform methods, doctrines, litigation steps, and trial processes. It includes case analysis, procedural rules, and the application of legal principles.

Preview 3 of 7 pages

See the first 3 pages exactly as they appear in the document.

  1. Page 1
    Read page 1 as text

    CIV3701 Civil Procedure Assignment No.l Due Date: 3 April 2025 QUESTION 1 (a) Briefly describe three methods which may be used to reform civil procedure. The first way in which to reform civil procedure is by means of the continual revision of the rules of court . Another method is to increase the jurisdictional limits of the lower courts to give more people access to court , but at a lower cost than would be the case of access to a High Court. Another method of reform is t o exclude, in part or in whole, specific types of disputes from the court system . A good example of an Act that does this is the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 *, which both prescribes dispute resolution procedures and establishes courts that deal with labour matters only 2 . (b) Briefly describe the doctrine of effectiveness. The doctrine of effectiveness is a fundamental principle in common law that underpins the exercise of jurisdiction. A court will refrain from exercising its jurisdiction unless it can render a judgment that is effective, meaning that compliance with the judgment is anticipated. If the defendant resides in the jurisdiction of a South African court, the judgment against them can be enforced through executory measures, such as the attachment of property by the sheriff. Conversely, if the defendant is a foreign perengrenus , the court permits the issuance of an effective judgment by allowing the attachment of their property ad confirmandum/ findandum/ fundandum jurisdictionem within South Africa to establish jurisdiction, thereby ensuring that the court can deliver an enforceable judgment 3 . QUESTION 2 1 Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 Civil Procedure (2018), Only Study Guide CIV3701, Pretoria, South Africa: University of South Africa. CLS cc, Civil Procedure Notes (2018)

  2. Page 2
    Read page 2 as text

    A drive through a red traffic light and collides with B's motor vehicle. B suffers damages in the amount of R420 000. B lives and works in Johannesburg. A lives in Pretoria. B wishes to issue a summons against A in the magistrates' court for damages suffered. (a) Explain whether any regional magistrates' court can be competent to exercise jurisdiction? Section 28(l)(d) of the Magistrates' Court Act 32 of 1944 4 establishes that a magistrates' court holds jurisdiction over an individual if the cause of action occurred entirely within the district or regional division. In terms of Monetary Jurisdiction, the regional Magistrates' Court handles civil claims exceeding R200 000 but not more than R1 million. B's claim is R420 000, it falls within the regional court's jurisdiction. The court can hear cases where the defendant (A) resides, works, or conducts business, or where the cause of action arose. A resides in Pretoria, while B resides in Johannesburg. The appropriate court will be determined based on where the accident occurred. From the facts given, the accident occurred in Pretoria, the Pretoria Regional Magistrates' Court has jurisdiction. If it occurred in Johannesburg, B may approach the Johannesburg Regional Magistrates' Court 5 . (c) Assume on the same facts that A owes B an amount of R20 000 for services rendered by B to A, the amount which A admits. Will your answer in (a) above differ? Explain. (d) the Magistrates' Courts, even though they may involve amounts of R400 000 The regional magistrates' court is not authorised to process claims that are less than R200,000. Given that B's claim for services provided amounts to only R20,000, it is within the jurisdiction of the District Magistrates' Court. The appropriate court to address this issue is the District Magistrates' Court located in either A's place of residence (Pretoria) or where the debt originated 6 . Magistrates' Court Act 32 of 1944 CLS cc, Civil Procedure Notes (2018) CLS cc, Civil Procedure Notes (2018) 2

  3. Page 3
    Read page 3 as text

    Further to the above, section 39 of the Magistrates' Court Act 32 of 1944 7 allows a plaintiff to subtract any amount they acknowledge as owed to the defendant from their claim. According to Section 28(1)(a) of the same Act, a district or regional court has jurisdiction over individuals who live, conduct business, or are employed within its jurisdictional area. If plaintiff B deducts the recognised debt of R20,000 owed to A from the total claim, the remaining amount of R400,000 still falls within the monetary jurisdiction limit of the regional magistrates' court. Furthermore, since A resides in Pretoria, the Pretoria regional court possesses the authority to adjudicate this case under Section 28(1)(a). As a result, the conclusion differs from (a) because jurisdiction__now _lies _with _a _regional __court in _Pretoria. __Section __38 _of the Magistrates' Courts Act 32 of 1944 8 is not applicable in this scenario, as the facts specifically highlight an acknowledged debt owed to the defendant ____ 9 . (d) Briefly explain how the audi alteram partem principle finds application in the ordinary application procedure. Audi alteram partem principled is maxim means to "hear the other side". The principle emphasizes the importance of considering 'the other side.' Every individual has the right to present their case before any ruling or decision is made against them. This underscores the necessity of utilising process documents and pleadings. Both parties are informed about the foundation of each other's claims, enabling them to respond effectively. Consequently, this practice ensures that neither party is not taken by surprise or unprepared during the trial 10 . The audi alteram partem principle establishes that the standard practice requires that all parties whose rights might be impacted by a court order, or who have an interest in such an order, must be notified of the litigation. However, an ex parte application allows a court to hear a case without notifying any parties, which indicates that this type of application serves as an 7 Magistrates' Court Act 32 of 1944 Magistrates' Courts Act 32 of 1944 CLS cc, Civil Procedure Notes (2018 ) 10 StuDocu.com, Civils Notes (2018) 3

4 more pages in the full document

Unlock it once and it stays in your library, ready to chat with or turn into flashcards.

Unlock the full document

More Civil Law study materials

See all

Study this document with CramX

Once it is in your library, every tool can work from it.