Skip to content
Class Notes

Inconsistencies in Cth and State Laws

Summary of key High Court cases on inconsistencies between Commonwealth and State laws under s109 of the Australian Constitution, including major tests like conflict of duties, modification of rights, and covering the field.

Preview 4 of 12 pages

See the first 4 pages exactly as they appear in the document.

  1. Page 1
    Read page 1 as text

    Cases 1 - INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN CTH AND STATE LAWS INVALIDITY Wen v Attorney General Illawarra Council v Whickam Butler vA-G of Vic (1961) INCONSISTENCY Australian Boot Trade Employees Federation v Whybrow (1910) The Cth industrial award requiring employees in the boot trade to be paid a minimum wage of 1 shilling, 1 1/2 pence per hour. There was a Victorian law requiring a minimum wage of 1 shilling per hour. HELD: it is possible to obey both laws - no inconsistency R v Licensing Court of Brisbane; Ex Parte Daniell (1920) Federal law prohibited the holding of a vote of referendum of voters of a State on a day appointed for voting for a federal election. Qld law required a State referendum to be held on the same day as a particular federal election. HELD: Qld electoral officials could not obey both laws. There was a conflict of duties and therefore a direct inconsistency. Colvin v Bradley Bros Pty Ltd ( 1 943) NSW law prohibited the employment of women on milling machines. Federal award explicitly permitted the employment of women (unless a Board of Reference made a declaration to the contrary, but no such declaration was relevantly made). HELD: There was an inconsistency between the State duty not to employ and the federal right (liberty) to employ - looks like a new test of modification of rights? Clyde Engineering Co Ltd v Cowbum (1926) A state law fixed ordinary working hours in the engineering industry at 44 hours, with overtime entitlements for additional hours. A Cth industrial award fixed pay rates and overtime on the basis of a 48-hour week, and gave employers the right to deduct pay from employees working less than the 48 hours. Cowburn relied on the State act to work only a 44 hour week, and claimed full award wages. His employer, relying on the federal award, deducted 9s 4d from his wages. DISSENTING: (Higgins and Powers JJ) It is possible to obey both laws, by paying the full award wage for 44 hours of work. - conflict of duties test. HELD: (Knox CJ and Gavan Duffy J) 'One statute is inconsistent with another when it takes away a right conferred by that other...' - modification of rights argument (Isaacs J): 'no doubt the employer could obey both, that is physically. ...But surely the vital question would be: was the second Act on its true construction intended to cover the whole ground and, therefore, to supersede the first?' - Covering the field argument - the tests operate concurrently. Intention of the legislators to cover the field. Ex parte McLean (1930) The NSW and Cth law: □ stipulated the same 'rule of conduct' (employees must fulfil their employment contract), but □ imposed 'different penal sanctions' for a breach. HELD: there was an inconsistency - not on the first two tests, but the third (covering the field ) was applied. The Kakariki (1937) - 4th potential kind of inconsistency?? - operational 1

  2. Page 2
    Read page 2 as text

    Cases Vic act which authorised removal by State authorities of any ship sunk in a port within Victoria which had not been removed by the owner. Cth Act which Authorised removal by Cth authorities of any ship sunk on or near the coast of Australia. - two powers/liberties. The Kakariki was a ship sunk in Port Phillip Bay, Vic. Neither the Cth nor the State authorities had exercised their powers to remove the ship. HELD: Latham CJ: there was no inconsistency - no 'express' inconsistency as each law merely confers power on an authority to do an act. □ no conflict of duties □ no modification of a right by a conflicting duty □ no intention to cover the field (Cth law does not prohibit anyone other than the Cth authority from revoking the wreck) An.inconsist.ency could arise if Cth and State authorities both attempted to exercise their powers. Dixon J: When a State law, if valid, would alter, impair or detract from the operation of the Commonwealth Parliament, then to that extent it is invalid. Moreover, if it appears from the terms, the nature or the subject matter of a Federal enactment that it was intended as a complete statement of the law governing a particular matter or set of rights and duties, then for a State law to regulate or apply to the same matter or relation is regarded as a detraction from the full operation of the Commonwealth law and so as inconsistent. at 630 Evatt J: Whether and to what extent a law of a State is inconsistent with a law of the Commonwealth cannot be determined by any rule of universal application... I have endeavoured to point out the very great difficulties inherent in... regarding a State law as "inconsistent" with a Commonwealth law because the latter either "covers the field" or "expresses an intention to cover the field." Any analogy between legislation with its infinite complexities and varieties and the picture of a two-dimensional field seems to me to be of little assistance... the new idea of "covering the field" was introduced at about the same time as the Engineers' Case called in aid a doctrine of Commonwealth "supremacy" expressly based upon s 109 of the Constitution. Wenn v Attorney-General (Vic) (1948) Dixon J's fine distinction The Cth: □ can legislate 'exhaustively to the intent that the areas of liberty designedly left should not be closed up' □ cannot undertake a 'bare attempt to exclude State concurrent power from a subject the Federal legislature has not effectively dealt with by regulation, control or otherwise' Native Title Act case (1995) Mason CJ, Brennan, Dean, Toohey, Gaudron and McHugh JJ: Where it is within the legislative competence of the Commonwealth Parliament to prescribe an exclusive statutory regime a Commonwealth law which merely expresses an exclusion of the operation of a State law is not construed as an attempt to invalidate the State law directly. It is construed as a declaration of intention that the Commonwealth law should operate exclusively of State law on the topic, that Commonwealth law is within power. Unless the Commonwealth law were expressed in terms which precluded that construction, the form of expression does not take the law outside the Commonwealth power. COVERING THE FIELD TEST IMPLIED INTENTION *"Ansell v Wardley (1980) Under an agreement given force by federal law, employers were entitled to employ and dismiss airline pilots, subject to conditions in the agreement. State law prohibited discrimination on the ground of sex in employment and dismissal decisions. Argument (Ansett): that the federal law conferred a right in general terms to employ and dismiss pilots; the State law modified that right. Alternatively, the federal law intended to cover the field. HELD: Stephen J: what is the subject matter of both laws? o the subject matter of the State law is discrimination on the basis of sex 2

  3. Page 3
    Read page 3 as text

    Cases o the subject matter of the agreement given force by federal law is the 'settlement of an entirely orthodox industrial dispute' concerning relations between particular employers and employees □ therefore these are different fields, no inconsistency (based on subject matter) Mason J: what is the intention (of the Federal legislators)? o it is not a 'general industry award' which exhaustively determines the respective right of employer and employee o it assumes the right at general law of employers to dismiss employees o it merely regulates the procedure and means by which such general law rights are exercised o the federal law leaves room for State law to define the general law concerning employment, such as imposing a prohibition of discrimination. □ Therefore there is no inconsistency based on the Cth's intention. O'Sullivan v Noarlunga Meat Ltd (1954) State law and federal law provided for separate licensing or registration regimes regarding the slaughtering of stock for export: □ federal law prohibited the export of meat unless it had been treated and stored in a 'registered' establishment □ state law prohibited the use of premises for slaughtering stock for export without a licence Noarlunga was registered under the Cth law , but did not have a State licence and was prosecuted under the State Act. Fullagar J: (4/7 majority) - what is the character of the law? □ the subject matter of both laws is the same □ the federal law imposed an extremely elaborate and detailed set of requirements □ this showed an intention to express completely and exhaustively the requirements of law with respect to the subject matter □ intention of the law is therefore to cover the field Taylor J (dissenting) - what is the subject matter? □ different- the state law was concerned with the establishment of abattoirs, the federal law concerned with licences for exporting meat □ the federal law did not cover the field EXPRESS INTENTION Viskauskas v Niland (1983) - discrimination case George and Stella Viskauskas ran a hotel in Kempscy. Three people of aboriginal descent complained they were refused service on the ground of race. The (Cth) Commissioner for Community Relations commenced an inquiry under the federal Racial Discrimination Act . The three complainants made a separate complaint under the NSW Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 . □ Cth Anti-Discrimination laws now generally have a clause which mean that State laws continue to operate (as in a not intending to cover the field clause) HELD: There was an inconsistency. The federal law covered the entire field of 'racial discrimination'. It was expressed 'with complete generality', and it had to operate 'equally and without discrimination in all States - with no exceptions under State laws. The State law dealt with the same subject matter in 'substantially similar terms', but with different consequences for breach, thus prescribing different rules of conduct. Legislative response: Enactment of s 6A(1), RDA: This Act is not intended, and shall be deemed never to have been intended, to exclude or limit the operation of a law of a State or Territory that furthers the objects of the Convention and is capable of operating concurrently with this Act. ONE YEAR LATER: University of Wollongong v Metwally (1984) Mr Metwally was an Egyptian postgrad student at Wollongong Uni. He lodged complaints under the NSW Anti-Discrimination Act. These complaints were made within the period of purported retrospective operation of s 6A(1) RDA. He was awarded damages by the NSW Equal Opportunity tribunal, and the university challenged the finding on the basis that s 6A(1) was invalid so far as it purported to have a retrospective operation. 3

  4. Page 4
    Read page 4 as text

    Cases HELD: All agree that s 109 means that the State laws are 'inoperative', not 'invalid'. They also all agree that the Commonwealth can validly pass retrospective laws (with the caveat of criminal laws). So, is there something unusual about the operation of the constitution? Gibbs CJ: Avoiding the operation of s 109 retrospectively would: □ 'vary the effect which s 109 had produced at the relevant time' □ 'deprive s 109... of its operation' Cth laws cannot prevail over the operation and effect of the Constitution: U S 109 is of 'great importance for the ordinary citizen, who is entitled to know which of two inconsistent laws he is required to observe' Deane J: Australia is fundamentally a 'union of people' □ the const is 'ultimately concerned with the governance and protection of the people from whom the artificial entities called the commonwealth and states derive their authority' □ s 1 09 serves the 'important function of protecting the individual from the injustice of being subjected to the requirements of inconsistent laws of the commonwealth and state parliaments on the same subject.' Therefore the Commonwealth cannot retrospectively avoid the operation of s 109---------- DISSENTING: Mason J: si 09 operates on actual inconsistency □ the Cth cannot enable a State law to operate when in fact there is an inconsistency □ However, inconsistency in fact only exists by virtue of federal laws, and their effect depends on the terms and intention of those laws H Thus, federal laws can remove the fact of inconsistency - i.e. by expressing an intention not to cover the field. □ what Parliament can do prospectively, it can do retrospectively □ Parliament can therefore retrospectively remove the inconsistency upon which s 109 operates, by expressing an intention not to have covered the field.

8 more pages in the full document

Unlock it once and it stays in your library, ready to chat with or turn into flashcards.

Unlock the full document
See all

Study this document with CramX

Once it is in your library, every tool can work from it.