Skip to content
Class Notes

Section 109 of the Australian Constitution

Learn Section 109, detailing how inconsistencies between Commonwealth and State laws are resolved, including tests for validity, types of inconsistencies (direct, indirect, operational), legal principles, landmark cases, and exceptions.

Preview 3 of 7 pages

See the first 3 pages exactly as they appear in the document.

  1. Page 1
    Read page 1 as text

    | ET.EMF.NT 1: RELEVANT PROVISION. UNDER s 109. When a law of a State is inconsistent with a law of the Commonwealth, the latter shall prevail, and the former shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be invalid. L _______________ □ ELEMENT 2: ARE THE LAWS VALID?______________________________ For s109 to be invoked, there must be a valid Commonwealth law and a valid State law. IS THE C O M M O N W E A L T H LAW S U P P O R T E D BY A HEAD OF P O W E R ? If it states that it is supporte d by a head of power. Go through characterisation and the relevant test of characterisation. s 51(i) trade and commerce: Does the law concern international or interstate trade and commerce? If intrastate, is it incidental to it? E S 5 l(xx) Corporations power : is it related to a foreign corporation (incorporation case) or a trading or financial corporation (apply the activities test: Adamson's Case). o Does the law single out the constitutional corporation as the object of statutory command? Work Choices Case. S 51(ii) Taxation power : is it a tax that is being exacted? S 51(xxix) external affairs : o does the law relate to matters affecting Australia's relations with other countries? Thomas v Mowbray. o Does the law apply to a place, person, matter or thing geographically external to Australia? Seas and Submerged Lands Case o Does the law implement an international legal obligation? IS THE STATE LAW VALID? The legislative power of the States is 'plenary and ample': Union Steamship Co of Australia v King (1988) 166 CLR 1. o Where a State Law relates to an exclusive Commonwealth power (eg s.90 excise duties), it is invalid, so there is no need to rely on s.109. Conclude if the laws are valid. ELEMENT 3: WHAT KIND OF LAWS? SUB-ISSUE: WHAT KIND OF LAWS ARE REFERRED TO UNDER S 109? C State: the laws enacted by the state and federal parliament here, are [statutes] [statutory rales or regulations] [industrial awards] which are included under si 09. Is it a statutes/ legislation : Engineers' Case (1920) 28 CLR 129; E statutory rules and regulations : O'Sullivan v Noarlunga Meat Ltd (1954) 92 CLR 565; E industrial awards : eg, Ex parte Mclean (1930) 43 CLR 472; o CF: Does not include administrative orders or directions or Common law . ELEMENT 4: ARE THE LAWS INCONSISTENT ? STATE: There are two approaches to determine whether an inconsistency may arise between State and Commonwealth laws: Work Health Authority v Outback Ballooning ('Outback Ballooning') (2019) 266 CLR 428, 446-7 (Kiefel CJ, Bell, Keane, Nettle and Gordon JJ).

  2. Page 2
    Read page 2 as text

    1. Does the State law alter, impair or detract from the operation of a Commonwealth law, giving rise to a direct inconsistency? Victoria v Commonwealth ('The Kakariki') (1937) 58 CLR 618, 630 (Dixon J). 2. Does the Commonwealth law express an intention to 'completely, exhaustively, or exclusively, what shall be the law governing the particular conduct or matter to which its attention is directed'? Ex parte McLean (1930) 43 CLR 472, 483. IS IT DIRECT INCONSISTENCY: CONFLICT OF DUTIES □ Is it impossible to simultaneously obey both laws : Ex parte Daniell; Australian Mutual Provident Society v Goulden. Draw analogies or distinguish with these cases. a. govt activities: where it was held that one can't attend a state referendum at the same time as a federal senate election: R v Brisbane Licensing Court; Ex parte Daniell (1920) 28 CLR 33 R v Brisbane Licensing Court; Ex parte Daniell (1920) 28 CLR 33 The Liquor Act 1912 (Qld) required a referendum on liquor trading hours to be held on the same day as the federal Senate election. However, the Commonwealth Electoral Act provided that a State referendum could not be held on the same day as a federal Senate election. Held: State law was inconsistent with the Commonwealth law under s 109 and the Commonwealth law prevailed as there was a clear onflict where one could not obey both laws simultaneously. b. Insurance schemes : Australian Mutual Provident Society v Goulden Australian Mutual Provident Society v Goulden(1986) 160 CLR 330. In this case, the plaintiff was a visually impaired person who took an insurance out and sought to vary the policy by adding a waiver of premium benefit in the event of his disablement for the period that he is disabled. Issue: a direct inconsistency arose between the NSW Anti-Discrimination Actand the Commonwealth Life Insurance Act The inconsistency arose because the Commonwealth law required that premium rates for insurance policies be approved by an actuary, taking into account various risk factors, including physical impairments. The NSW Anti- Discrimination Act, on the other hand, prohibited denying goods or services based on disablement, which effectively prevented insurers from considering physical impairments when setting premiums. The court determined that the state law's prohibition interfered with the essential function of life insurance businesses to classify risks and set premiums appropriately. As a result, the Commonwealth law, which is supreme in cases of inconsistency, rendered the NSW law inapplicable to the extent of the conflict. This decision underscored the principle that Commonwealth legislation takes precedence over state laws when there is a direct inconsistency, TYPE OF DIRECT INCONSISTENCY: CONFLICT OF RIGHTS □ Is there an inconsistent rights or duties. Ask yourself: is it possible to obey both the laws even if they are inconsistent? I I The State law alters, impairs or detracts from the Commonwealth law, because: o by granting a right, the Commonwealth law intends that the right should be capable of being exercised: Colvin v Bradley Brothers where the state law was held to be inconsistent because it said women were not allowed to work in mills while Cwth law permitted women to work in mills. Was possible to obey both laws but held inconsistent as rights were taken away by NSW. o criminal conduct that Commonwealth law intends should not be criminal : Dickson v The Queen (2010) 241 CLR 491 where there was a drect inconsistency as the state law imposed greater obligations on the appellant than those provided by the federal law.

  3. Page 3
    Read page 3 as text

    □ Cf with Ansett where Grant of a mere right or permission by a Commonwealth law will not necessarily render relevant state laws inoperative: Ansett Transport; Commercial radio Dickson v The Queen (201 0) 241 CLR 491 Here, there was a Federal offence of conspiracy to steal Commonwealth property that was intended to operate in narrow circumstances. State law had a much broader conspiracy to steal property offence and therefore criminalized conduct that the Commonwealth law intended should not be unlawful. Held: there was a direct inconsistency, in that the State law altered, impaired and detracted from the operation of the Commonwealth law. In considering it as a direct inconsistency, was the fact that the state law, if allowed to operate, would impose upon the appellant obligations greater than those provided by the federal law'. Colvin v Bradley Brothers Pty Ltd (1943) 68 CLR 151. NSW law prohibited the employment of women to work on milling machines. Commonwealth industrial award permitted employment of women to work on milling machines. It was possible to obey both laws, since nothing in the Commonwealth law required the employment of women. However, it was held to be a direct inconsistency because the NSW law was directly inconsistent with the federal law. Held: the State law was inconsistent with the operation of the Commonwealth law and section 109 was applied to override the state law. CF with the cases below to see if the cth law is subject to applicable state laws. EXCEPTIONS: WHEN THERE IS NO DIRECT INCONSISTENCY: a. Grant of a mere right or permission by a Commonwealth law will not necessarily render relevant state laws inoperative: Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd v Wardley (1980) 142 CLR 237 Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd v Wardley (1980) 142 CLR 237 Ansett employees were governed by a Commonwealth award for airline pilots. Ansett refused to employ Wardley due to her sex which was in violation of the Equal Opportunity Act Ansett argued that the state laws were invalid as Cth law allowed it to dismiss someone within six months after giving notice. Held: the Commonwealth award did not exempt Ansett from complying with the Equal Opportunity Act 1977 (Vic). The Commonwealth law that conferred a right to termination did not evince an intention to operate to the exclusion of any state anti-discrimination laws. Further, they operated to legislate different subject matters. b. Commercial Radio Coffs Harbour v Fuller (1986) 161 CLR 47. Commercial Radio Coffs Harbour Court found that there was no inconsistency with the state law. A Commonwealth licence for a new commercial radio station had been given under the Broadcasting and Television Act 1942 (Cth). A condition of the licence required the erection of two antennae each 170 metres high. Court held that the antenna could be constructed without breaching state planning laws. Court held that the penalties imposed for non-compliance with the licence conditions did not require licensees to disobey state law of environmental planning. Licence didn't give a positive right to disobey state laws. CONCLUSION: determine if there is a direct inconsistency. There can be direct and indirect inconsistency at times as well.

4 more pages in the full document

Unlock it once and it stays in your library, ready to chat with or turn into flashcards.

Unlock the full document
See all

Study this document with CramX

Once it is in your library, every tool can work from it.