State Judicial Power Limitations
- Civil Law
- 7 pages
- Shared June 2025
This summary outlines the limits of state judicial power under the Kable principle, examining how laws must not compromise the institutional integrity of state courts when they may exercise federal judicial power under the Constitution.
Preview 3 of 7 pages
See the first 3 pages exactly as they appear in the document.
Page 1 Read page 1 as text
STATE JUDICIAL POWER LIMITATIONS □ STARTING STATEMENT: The QLD parliament has plenary and ample legislative power to make laws for the peace, welfare and good government of the state: Union Steamship Coal; Durham holdings. However, under the Kable principle, there is a limit on the legislative power of the state parliaments. Does the law confer power on a State (or Territory) court that may sometimes exercising federal judicial power (a Chapter III Court)? ____________________________________________ TT Is it a supreme court of a state? State: State Supreme courts are repository of federal judicial power: ss 71, 77(iii) of the constitution. Because of the integrated judicial system, while there is no strict separation of powers at the state level, a State parliament cannot confer a power upon a court which substantially impairs the courts institutional integrity and is therefore incompatible with the state court's role as a (Kable; Emmerson). Is the power incompatible with the institutional integrity of the court as a potential repository of federal jurisdiction? (ie in breach of the Kable principle?) _____________________ a) Significant deviation from ordinary judicial process. i. not citing reasons: a. was held to be invalid in Wainohu where judge was acting persona designata but counterargument that it was a non-judicial power failed as Kable applies on personal capacity of judges as well: Wainohu. Cf with Grollo v Palmer . ii. closed court, ex parte proceedings : a. allow courts to decide that particular information is confidential from a party: i. Gypsy jokers: was held to be ok in Gypsy Jokers as there was a criteria for the court to apply to decide whether material is confidential and have closed court; so not directed by the executive. ii. Pompano: Was held to be ok in Pompano as well where court decided whether to declare a body as crim org based on evidence. Had independence to decide what weight to give to the evidence and that the def cant defend it. have to balance procedural unfairness against prejudice to the investigation if open disclosure occurred. b. Cf with international Financial trust where ex parte hearings was held invalid despite the fact that the court had independence to decide if it had reasonable grounds to suspect someone was engaged in criminal activity, the ex parte hearing made it impossible for them to defend themselves, thus, held to be invalid. iii. Alter the burden or standard of proof, including in criminal matters: c. Momcilovic(2011): In Momcilovic; the law had changed the burden of proof where if drugs found in your house, oyu arc deemed to be trafficking drugs. The def argued that it breached the Kable principle due to lack of procedural fairness. Held: not unfair as changing the burden of proof didn't undermine the integrity of the judicial process or the courts. d. Emmerson v NT(2014): In Emmerson's case , there was automatic forfeiture of property if declared as a drug trafficker. The legislation could declare anyone as a drug trafficker if they committed the offence within the
Page 2 Read page 2 as text
last 10 years. HCA said the law was valid as it did not undermine the integrity of the court by making an order based on past conduct. iv. Appoint acting judges: was held to be valid in Forge where the argument that acting judges in the SC of NSW deprived them of independence because they did not have longterm security of tenure was rejected because it held that it is not a defining characteristic that the court be only composed of permanent fulltime judges. b) Interferes with independence of courts a. lack of discretion of the court where AG declared who was a crim org and then court had to make a control order was held invalid as it was directed by the Executive: Totani i. CF with Kuczborski, where it was held that determining an organisation as a criminal organisation by AG was ok as it was not the offence creating provision . Court still had to apply criteria to determine if the other elements of the offence were satisfied before imposing punishment: Kuczborski. b. Ad-hominem laws are considered against the principle of judicial independence as seen as doing the executive's bidding: Kable where the legislation was specifically designed to only keep Kable in detention. This was non-judicial as it was for future conduct and the Parliament is making orders via the court which isn't the court's job. i. Cf with Knight v Victoria , where the law was ad-hominem but it was the parole board that decided not to relase a prisoner unless they are dying or severely incapacitated. Here, beucase parole board is not a chapter III court, it was held to be ok. c. Mandatory aggravated penalty is not contrary to integrity of courts where in Magaming, the an aggravated offence meant a greater sentence for the 19 year old accused. HCA held that the minimum sentence range was anterior to judicial proceedings and a matter of legislative concern, thus, enacting the minimum sentence was not inconsistent with judicial integrity. Plus, the court could still take his age into account when sentencing. d. Mandatory penalty based on past conduct is ok Emmerson: In Emmerson's case , there was automatic forfeiture of property if declared as a drug trafficker. The legislation could declare anyone as a drug trafficker if they committed the offence within the last 10 years. HCA said the law was valid as it did not undermine the integrity of the court by making an order based on past conduct. e. require courts to make a particular order if certain criteria are met: i. Emmerson; there was automatic forfeiture of property if declared as a drug trafficker. The legislation could declare anyone as a drug trafficker if they committed the offence within the last 10 years. HCA said the law was valid as it did not undermine the integrity of the court by making an order based on past conduct. ii. Kuczborski here it was held that the offences that prevented members of a crim org to not associate with each other or face severe penalty was held valid, as the declaration made by A-G that K was a member of a crim org was not the offence creating provison. It was merely a prerequisite. iii. Fardon : law was held valid because Court has a discretion to determine whether there is 'unacceptable risk', according to criteria. Court has discretion as to whether an order should be made, and the type of order. Rules of evidence apply, and hearings are conducted in public.
Page 3 Read page 3 as text
iv. Vella: law that prevented people who had serious convictions to be subject to control order if court had reasonable grounds to believe they would be danger to community was held valid because draconian laws do not invalidate the integrity of the court unless they deprive the court of its decisional capacity. Here, the harsh laws made were anterior to the judicial process and therefore, it is not invalid. v. Garlett: court had to make mandatory detention order but it still had discretion to decide whether there was an unacceptable risk and if the order was necessary. f. Parliament deciding which offences are serious offences is ok : i. Garlett where HCA rejected that Executive's decision to include robbery as a serious crime was exaggerated and deprived the court of its institutional independence. Court rejected the argument that bad or unjust laws affect the institutional integrity of the courts as it is not the court's job to make laws, it's the Parliament. g. Laws that Laws that prevent serious criminals from obtaining parole have been upheld by the HCA. i. Baker: Continue detention of serious offenders was considered valid in baker where the plaintiff argued that the court not being able to set a non-parole period for certain prisoners unless there were 'special reasons' was rejected because it appeared the court was doing the executive's bidding. HCA held that special reasons was a valid legislative drafting to encompass all the special circumstances the court could take into consideration. ii. Fardon : continued detention of the prisoner after the end of their sentence was ordered if there is an unacceptable risk that the prisoner would commit based on a high degree of probability. It was held vlaid as it was not an ad hominem law and court had to apply criteria to decide whether there was an unacceptable risk. Also they had right of appeal. Conclusion: ________________________________________________________________________ □ Decide whether the law breaches the Kable principle or not. o If the law breaches the Kable principle, the consequence is it is invalid . Case summaries: Magaming the def charged with the offence of smuggling people into Australia carried a penalty of up to 20 years and earned a minimum sentence of 5 years. The def was a 19 year old Indonesian fisherman who argued that the minimum sentencing was arbitrary and non-judicial. Held valid as sentencing and providing sentence range is a legislative function. Baker v the Queen Sentencing Act : Section 13A of the Sentencing Act j989 (NSW) allows life sentences to be commuted to fixed terms for
4 more pages in the full document
Unlock it once and it stays in your library, ready to chat with or turn into flashcards.
Unlock the full documentMore Civil Law study materials
See all
Class NotesClass Notes For Legal Terminology, 6th Edition
Civil Law
168 pages149downloadsFeb 2025
Class NotesLecture Notes for Introduction to Law, 7th Edition
Civil Law
310 pages121downloadsFeb 2025
Past Exams2024-2025 TCOLE Basic Jailer Course Practice Exam with Answers (1401 Solved Questions)
Civil Law
84 pages72downloadsFeb 2025
Class NotesLecture Notes For Legal Research, Analysis, and Writing, 14th Edition
Civil Law
618 pages57downloadsFeb 2025
Solved AssignmentsAssessment 1 Long Answer Question
Civil Law
9 pagesJun 2025
Solved AssignmentsAlcohol Regulation
Civil Law
3 pagesMay 2025- Solved AssignmentsSolved Assignments
Ethical and Practical Challenges in Elder Law
Civil Law
1 pageJun 2025
Solved AssignmentsThe Evolution and Controversy of Habeas Corpus in the War on Terror
Civil Law
5 pagesMay 2025
Study this document with CramX
Once it is in your library, every tool can work from it.

