Skip to content
Solved Assignments

Unit VII Case Study Sleeping on the Job

A workplace ethics case study exploring employee misconduct, managerial responses, and disciplinary action following an incident of sleeping on the job, based on a scenario from Unit VII.

Preview 3 of 7 pages

See the first 3 pages exactly as they appear in the document.

  1. Page 1
    Read page 1 as text

    1 Unit VII Case Study: Sleeping on the Job Carissa Perlongo Columbia Southern University HRM 4304: Collective Bargaining Professor: Sheila Baldwin-Boston April 08,2025

  2. Page 2
    Read page 2 as text

    2 Unit VII Case Study: Sleeping on the Job Introduction In case study 11-2 of our textbook, we are asked to examine the dismissal of a union truck driver who was observed on multiple occasions asleep or appearing to be asleep in the cab of his truck while on duty. The company cites safety concerns and provides documented history of similar incidents as justification for his termination. The union challenges this decision based on the credibility of the company's evidence and argues against the inconsistency in their disciplinary actions and the probability of what actually occurred with a witness from another union representative who ended up never giving testimony (Carrell & Heavrin, 2013). Upon reading the case I will break down the following questions on what I have learned thus far. Should the First Two Infractions Influence the Outcome of the Case? The way in which a company handles incidents on the job sets the tone to how they will be managed in future occurrences so it is important for a company to follow consistent guidelines in each situation. At the time of the first incident in the summer of 2008, the supervisor failed to provide sufficient documentation or evidence of an incident. The supervisor instead took an informal approach to the truck driver being asleep on the job, which suggests that the company may not have viewed it as a critical incident at the time (Carrell & Heavrin, 2013). Being this was the first incident, it is a possibility the supervisor was issuing an informal ‘warning; however, it should still be documented as without documentation it does not factor into the decision-making process. In the second incident, the supervisor issued a safety observation card and had a counseling session with the truck driver and his union steward (Carrell & Heavrin, 2013). This outlined a clear expectation moving forward and warned the employee of the future

  3. Page 3
    Read page 3 as text

    3 consequences if another incident was to occur, to include being discharged. Again, this incident was merely a safety observation and not a formal action of discipline which in other words could be seen as the company not deeming sleeping on the job as an immediate terminable offense. It did however lay a clear outline to the employee that if they were witnessed again appearing to be asleep, they would be discharged from their position, without question. This incident alone could play in the company's favor to their justification for termination especially on how they view the safety procedures and regulation of their handbook. In the third incident, the truck driver was observed by the supervisor and the backhoe driver asleep for several minutes in a running truck. Once the supervisor reported to this management, it became a formal incident and the employee was discharged as per his previous warnings. The company outlines that the employee violated a clearly communicated policy and yet continued to risk the safety of those around him by not being observant at all times while his truck was being loaded (Carrell & Heavrin, 2013). While the company displayed inconsistent enforcement of disciplinary actions for similar incidents, I do feel that the first two incidents should influence the outcome of the case. In the span of less than a year, this employee has been witnessed on three occasions violating safety regulations and in the second incident, was informed of the seriousness in which his actions held. On the third account, it has become a trend and while the union could argue about inconsistent enforcement or evidence for termination, their main witness to the third incident did not show up to testify at the hearing, which can be seen as his agreement that the employee was asleep. Overall, the enforcement of the safety and regulations after several incidents may play a higher card especially when someone is showing a recognizable trend in the workforce.

4 more pages in the full document

Unlock it once and it stays in your library, ready to chat with or turn into flashcards.

Unlock the full document
See all

Study this document with CramX

Once it is in your library, every tool can work from it.